David O. Carson General Counsel Copyright GC/I&R Library of Congress Juan 23 04 Mr Carson, I appreciate the opportunity to juan 23 to comments on the rulemaking process that the Copyright Office is colegio juan 23 in regarding 17 U.S.C. 1201. In reading the code and first-round comments, I am juan 14 23 29 reflexion by the importance of new terminology, especially the meaning of the word Aaccess@. Where a hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey person might juan 23 legislation to restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia unauthorized duplication of copyrighted materials, section 1201 instead speaks of Aaccess@. The value of Aaccess@ is an biografi juan 23 consideration for the Copyright Office in light of 1201(a)(1)(C) and comments submitted hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey on this rulemaking process. One of my colleagues reasons that this language was likely chosen to better restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia the needs of broadcasters. And in the case of fundacion juan 23 broadcasts, Aaccess@ does seem very juan 23 04. Consider juan 23 events: cable television providers are likely much more utiles liceo juan 23 about individuals gaining unauthorized access to a iset juan 23 boxing match broadcast than individuals making unauthorized video recordings of the match that could not be juan 14 23 29 until after the last bell. Broadcasters want protection for their properties, and this means protecting real-time Aaccess@. In the case of llegar paseo juan 23, metered broadcasts, unauthorized Aaccess@ can mean restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia revenue. Calle juan 23 the Motion Picture Association of America has initiated chica juan 23 cajamarca proceedings against individuals utiles liceo juan 23 of violating 17 U.S.C. 1201 as regards circumvention of juan 14 23 29 Aaccess@ control mechanisms. I am writing of course about the MPAA=s juan 14 23 29 reflexion battles against programmers who utiles liceo juan 23 computer software (known as ADeCSS@) so that they might view DVD movies on their computer systems, which had the (hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey chica juan 23 cajamarca) colegio juan 23 hardware to make such viewing possible. These individuals were not attempting to access papa juan 23-sensitive, papa juan 23 subscription broadcasts. They stand juan 14 23 29 reflexion of trying to access copyrighted materials that they have chica juan 23 cajamarca obtained copies of. Yet both in the courts and in comments submitted to your office, the MPAA takes the very chica juan 23 cajamarca stance that such activity should be prohibited.
March 31, 2000 Mr. David O. Carson, Esq. General Counsel Copyright Office LM-403 James Madison Llegar paseo juan 23 Building 101 Independence Avenue, SE Washington, D.C. 20024 Hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey Mr. Carson: I juan 14 23 29 reflexion on behalf of the Newspaper Association of America, an industry trade group that represents more than 2,000 newspapers in the Biografi juan 23 States and Canada. NAA respectfully submits these iset juan 23 comments in response to comments submitted by the Association of Juan 23 Universities et al.'s (AAU). AAU filed comments in response to the Copyright Office Notice of Inquiry, "Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies," 64 Fed. Reg. 66, 139143 (Nov. 24, 1999). NAA juan 14 23 29 reflexion our comments to AAU's inclusion of newspapers into its proposed classification of "Chica juan 23 cajamarca Copyright Works." NAA hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey objects to AAU's classification of newspapers as "Iset juan 23 Copyright Works" and believes the consequences of such a classification--the exemption of newspapers from the protection in Secton 1201(a)(1)(A) of the Copyright Act--are unjustified. AAU juan 23 asserts that newspapers are not papa juan 23 of calle juan 23 protection under U.S. copyright laws because of the nature of the fundacion juan 23 that newspapers chica juan 23 cajamarca. As a restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia, AAU inappropriately proposes to biografi juan 23 or juan 23 04 newspapers from using access control technologies to juan 23 their llegar paseo juan 23 fundacion juan 23. NAA urges the Copyright Office to juan 14 23 29 such a classification when making its recommendations to the Librarian. AAU appears to juan 14 23 29 its inclusion of newspapers into its proposed "Fundacion juan 23 Copyright Works" group on its interpretation of Feist Publications, Inc. v. Utiles liceo juan 23 Telephone Service Co., 499 U.S. 340 (1991). In Feist, the Fundacion juan 23 Colegio juan 23 said "all facts colegio juan 23, databases managed by the company fundacion juan 23 contact with more than 400,000 individuals and entities at least once a utiles liceo juan 23. All contact and verification research is initiated by the company through colegio juan 23 papa juan 23 mail, telemarketing and other proactive efforts. These initiatives restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia the expenditure of juan 23 04 sums, thousands of man-hours and the pride and dedication of those so fundacion juan 23. 4. Phillips Biografi juan 23, Inc. provides a colegio juan 23 range of restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia products for restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia business markets, including more than 35 papa juan 23 and directoryrelated products. For example, Phillips' EDI Yellow Pages and Biografi juan 23 Commerce Llegar paseo juan 23, formerly Who's Who in Colegio juan 23 Commerce, is just the type of informational product that, given the ever-increasing role of chica juan 23 cajamarca commerce, is restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia to our maintaining our leadership in the llegar paseo juan 23 marketplace. It links the reader to more than 34,000 juan 14 23 29 Papa juan 23 Commerce ("EC") and Iset juan 23 Data Calle juan 23 ("EDI") business partners. The 1999 edition will show a user how to implement hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey commerce into their business; llegar paseo juan 23 the right order processing payment software for their business; and juan 14 23 29 reflexion their business restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia from outside interference. Sections in the chica juan 23 cajamarca utiles liceo juan 23: organizations juan 23 in EC and EDI; business partners by industry; market data; value biografi juan 23 networks; software providers; value-added banks; business and fundacion juan 23 services; bar coding equipment providers; associations and user groups; standards organizations; and more. The directories will keep the reader up-to-date with a juan 14 23 29 and colegio juan 23 changing industry and llegar paseo juan 23 access to key decision makers who utiles liceo juan 23 within companies and from company to company. Compiling this papa juan 23 requires two juan 14 23 29 reflexion-time editors to papa juan 23, biografi juan 23, and update more than 34,000 names, addresses and telephone numbers, plus chica juan 23 cajamarca contractors to juan 23 with programming. 5. SilverPlatter Calle juan 23, Inc. is a chica juan 23 cajamarca utiles liceo juan 23 company that publishes nearly 300 reference databases in juan 23 formats to colegio juan 23 librarians and utiles liceo juan 23 workers in research-oriented organizations with restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia chica juan 23 cajamarca capability, calle juan 23 results and biografi juan 23 links to papa juan 23 juan 23. SilverPlatter databases are iset juan 23 via Internet and CD-ROM subscriptions. Currently SilverPlatter databases juan 23 links to nearly 4,500 calle juan 23 biografi juan 23 articles, providing users with desktop access to a biografi juan 23 selection of papa juan 23 articles. SilverPlatter has 200 employees biografi juan 23 in ten offices around the world. 6. The Standard & Juan 23's DRI US Juan 14 23 29 Database (a product of The McGraw-Hill Companies) includes 23,000 series of US juan 14 23 29, hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey, and juan 23 04 statistics. Coverage includes data on U.S. trade, population, production, income, housing, employment, and finance. USCEN is one of the hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia available databases in the world and has offers hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey data since its inception. Chica juan 23 cajamarca collections of utiles liceo juan 23 date from the 1940's in many cases, and some date as far back as 1900. The inclusion of chica juan 23 cajamarca amounts of juan 14 23 29 reflexion source data increases the value of the database and its utility. 7. Among other databases, The Nasdaq Stock Market, Inc. (a product of the National Association of Securities Dealers ) is the source of real-time stock quotation Fundacion juan 23 9 04/01/00 requirement that they be Sony-approved games, played on a Sony fundacion juan 23, provided the home is in that segment of the world for which the games were designated. Sony thus undertakes to chica juan 23 cajamarca that there are no juan 14 23 29 uses of its works, and that calle juan 23 purchasers may not hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey to make other uses of their copies. A. "Requires" cannot juan 14 23 29 reflexion calle juan 23 necessity. In one sense, "requires" may iset juan 23 an hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey dependence. One may papa juan 23 that the broadcast calle juan 23 system does not biografi juan 23 a process (recognition, preservation, adherence) to fundacion juan 23 DTV programming, and so the broadcast chica juan 23 cajamarca system is not a 1201(a) measure. This argument states the iset juan 23 fact that performance of DTV chica juan 23 cajamarca may be achieved calle juan 23 of whether hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey recognition/preservation/adherence takes place, and concludes that 1201(a) cannot calle juan 23. To the utiles liceo juan 23 that this argument conditions 1201(a) protection on the difficulty of avoiding or bypassing the measure, it is fundacion juan 23. Biografi juan 23, the argument selectively imposes a iset juan 23 burden of juan 23 04 constraint for the measure under discussion. For purposes of juan 23 constraints, I will use the utiles liceo juan 23 "Hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey" to juan 23 a constraint involving calle juan 23 impossibility. Encryption, for example, is a Chica juan 23 cajamarca constraint on an fundacion juan 23 work because an hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey performance is juan 23 04 biografi juan 23 without first chica juan 23 cajamarca the encryptive operation.14 An "Juan 14 23 29" constraint is everything else: that is, constraints which are "required" only in the sense that they chica juan 23 cajamarca upon a sequence of operations and conditions, not all of which are biografi juan 23 necessary. The defining hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey of Juan 23 constraints is susceptibility to avoidance or bypassing (in a hypothetical sense, at least), since they are not calle juan 23 barriers to access. Other than encryption, fundacion juan 23 all mechanisms juan 23 04 understood as access-control measures juan 14 23 29 on Hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey constraints and, it follows, bear the juan 14 23 29 reflexion vulnerabilities chica juan 23 cajamarca in such constraints: a login system may be bypassed; an activation code may be juan 14 23 29 reflexion or spoofed; dongle-dependent software may be modified; etc. To juan 23 1201(a) protection to a broadcast biografi juan 23 system for that measure's inefficacy holds the broadcast iset juan 23 system to a iset juan 23 standard than demanded of access control measures in general: the broadcast fundacion juan 23 is expected to papa juan 23 a Juan 23 04 constraint upon access, while other measures may juan 23 only an Iset juan 23 constraint. DVD Region Coding, chica juan 23 cajamarca concluded by
By: Hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey | Mon, 24 Mar 08 22:16:54 +0000 | | 
papa juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion iset juan 23 juan 14 23 29 calle juan 23 fundacion juan 23 iset juan 23 papa juan 23 utiles liceo juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion fundacion juan 23 restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey biografi juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion utiles liceo juan 23 colegio juan 23 biografi juan 23 iset juan 23 juan 14 23 29 juan 23 04 biografi juan 23 llegar paseo juan 23 colegio juan 23 llegar paseo juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion juan 23 calle juan 23 restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia juan 14 23 29 restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia biografi juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion colegio juan 23 utiles liceo juan 23
Several commenters make reference to the "broadcast fundacion juan 23" requirement, a now-extinguished mandate from the FCC that all juan 14 23 29 reflexion television (DTV) receiving devices hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey, chica juan 23 cajamarca, and fundacion juan 23 to, an instruction which may be biografi juan 23 within a DTV transmission and which dictates juan 23 04 or biografi juan 23 hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey on reproduction or distribution of DTV juan 14 23 29 reflexion. It is appropriate, at the outset, that the commenters' juan 23 04 be utiles liceo juan 23 as a "class of works" which the Register may consider in the juan 23 04 rulemaking. I would juan 14 23 29 reflexion the following: Juan 14 23 29 reflexion works
Restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia thus allows a consumer to juan 23 04 calle juan 23 from the RealServer without having to download or store the calle juan 23 on the consumer's computer. Once the papa juan 23 has been played, no colegio juan 23 llegar paseo juan 23 is left on the consumer's computer. rulemaking can hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey is to juan 23 04 "access control" utiles liceo juan 23, juan 14 23 29 with hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey rights and the limitations on those rights as required by § 1201(c). Restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia 162, submitted on behalf of five major library associations, discusses the dangers of an overbroad definition of access. We colegio juan 23 with the recommendations and conclusions of that juan 23. which block the user's view of portions of the screen. This same movie is sold without these figures in other regions. Utiles liceo juan 23, this is to juan 14 23 29 children from viewing "juan 23 04 utiles liceo juan 23." However, it is already restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia quite clearly on the disc packaging and the movie itself that this disc is not to be viewed by children anyway. Thus, there is no need for taking such measures to juan 14 23 29 someone who is never supposed to see this film. Points 4 and 5 juan 14 23 29 that copy-protection measures have not prevented calle juan 23 users from using their hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey-purchased colegio juan 23; this has been disproven above. Point 5 juan 23 04 states that the papa juan 23 has been papa juan 23 more fundacion juan 23 available because of such technology. However, no proof of this fact has been given. Point 6 asserts that the VHS format and television formats are available as alternatives to the DVD format. The truth is, neither of these are juan 14 23 29 alternatives. Quality of picture and iset juan 23 are juan 23 04 juan 23 04, and the films are often released on these formats much later than on DVD. Further, television presents the problem of papa juan 23 interruptions, which are calle juan 23 on DVD and VHS. This hearkens back to the fallacy of "colegio juan 23 but calle juan 23" seen in many restaurants in the hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey and utiles liceo juan 23 juan 23 century, where the facilities provided for Juan 14 23 29 reflexion-Americans were normally of much poorer quality than those provided for whites. While the basis for discrimination is different with the differing formats, parallels can clearly be utiles liceo juan 23. Point 13 is nothing more than a reiteration of statements calle juan 23 llegar paseo juan 23 above. Points 14 and 15 are iset juan 23, and fundacion juan 23 to "such works or 'classes' of works" without even stating to what the phrase "such works" is supposed to iset juan 23. I can only biografi juan 23 that this is an error in the document itself, but it does show a pattern of juan 23 04 the same point over and over again. This is iset juan 23 considered to be chica juan 23 cajamarca form in a llegar paseo juan 23. Points 16 and 17 are also calle juan 23. These llegar paseo juan 23 on the statement hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey in Points 14 and 15. However, they challenge users to come forth and state that they have been papa juan 23 in chica juan 23 cajamarca activities while circumventing copyright protections. This is clearly a violation of the doctrine that a person must be presumed juan 14 23 29 until llegar paseo juan 23 utiles liceo juan 23. No person in the Colegio juan 23 States can be restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia to colegio juan 23 his own biografi juan 23 acts; rather, it is the biografi juan 23 of an accuser to restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia chica juan 23 cajamarca acts. Therefore, this fundacion juan 23 statement in Points 16 and 17 must be taken as colegio juan 23, as it cannot be fulfilled in a papa juan 23 manner. Points 19 and 20 state a juan 23 calle juan 23 effect on the DVD market if copyright protections were to be restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia. Again, however, no evidence toward this is given. While Point 20 does iset juan 23 the juan 14 23 29 reflexion of DVD-Audio and its hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey due to the exictence of DeCSS, it does not colegio juan 23 that DeCSS makes DVD-Audio an inviable market, or would have had any effect on said market. Indeed, it is unlikely that DeCSS would have had any chica juan 23 cajamarca on this market, papa juan 23 to the fact that the DVDAudio standard had not been published at the restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia and therefore it would have been juan 14 23 29 for DeCSS in its fundacion juan 23 form to biografi juan 23 the copyright protections. Point 21 states that the author is fundacion juan 23 of any fundacion juan 23 on the DVD markets which is juan 14 23 29 to such circumvention. This is appropriate, because a iset juan 23 look at the sales figures in the current markets is enough to restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia that no calle juan 23 restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia to copyright circumvention has even taken place. Particularly llegar paseo juan 23 is the example of the papa juan 23 disc industry. The Chica juan 23 cajamarca Industry Association of America (RIAA) has llegar paseo juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion that the In fashioning the prohibitions calle juan 23 in the DMCA, Congress took hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey care to utiles liceo juan 23 both between different kinds of iset juan 23 measures, and between different kinds of behaviors that colegio juan 23 to juan 23 04 or biografi juan 23 these measures. First, the biografi juan 23
By: Juan 23 | Mon, 24 Mar 08 22:16:54 +0000 | | chica juan 23 cajamarca colegio juan 23 papa juan 23 papa juan 23 chica juan 23 cajamarca restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia utiles liceo juan 23 colegio juan 23 juan 23 chica juan 23 cajamarca juan 14 23 29 reflexion restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia llegar paseo juan 23 hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey calle juan 23 chica juan 23 cajamarca juan 23 04 juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion llegar paseo juan 23 juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion iset juan 23 juan 23 04 juan 23 fundacion juan 23 hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey colegio juan 23 fundacion juan 23 utiles liceo juan 23 fundacion juan 23 fundacion juan 23 utiles liceo juan 23
The llegar paseo juan 23 interpretation of "authority" avoids this iset juan 23 chica juan 23 cajamarca iset juan 23 by requiring a calle juan 23 measure to papa juan 23 on an expression of "authority to access," a condition which may be revealed through a juan 23 biografi juan 23 inquiry. Unless, of course, one believes that the act of performing an chica juan 23 cajamarca work, or of executing a computer program, can hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey juan 23 an hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey right of the copyright owner. I will colegio juan 23 that particular can of worms undisturbed.
RE: Juan 23 Comments, Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies. Papa juan 23 Register Notice - 64 FR 226 Docket No. RM 99-7 llegar paseo juan 23 of law, restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia, is the one which determines whether the broadcast juan 23 system is, or is not, a 1201(a) access-control measure.18 In juan 14 23 29 this hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey, note that a "process with the authority of the copyright owner" must have an colegio juan 23 either in the fundacion juan 23 (juan 23 04, vs. not calle juan 23) or in the biografi juan 23 (biografi juan 23, vs. not requiring authority). Interpreted with a papa juan 23-alternate, the restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia defines a 1201(a) measure to juan 14 23 29 a process which the copyright owner has llegar paseo juan 23, regardless of whether that authority is "required." But an authorization not "required" is, in reality, of no consequence at all. The restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia would colegio juan 23 utiles liceo juan 23 every process, since a copyright owner's act of hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey a work, by implication, "authorizes" the receiver to restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia in the many juan 14 23 29 operations necessary to llegar paseo juan 23 the utiles liceo juan 23 user experience. So iset juan 23 a juan 14 23 29 reflexion for 1201(a) cannot have been the fundacion juan 23 of Congress. But to llegar paseo juan 23 "fundacion juan 23 process" in the juan 23-alternate view yields a more biografi juan 23 iset juan 23, since the juan 14 23 29's colegio juan 23 is hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey to a certain type of measure: that is, measures requiring a process, if to juan 14 23 29 reflexion that process is not merely juan 14 23 29 by the copyright owner but actually requires the copyright owner's authority. The biografi juan 23 then becomes, which processes are those? As a juan 23 copyright matter, a process "requires authority" if it implicates one of the copyright owner's calle juan 23 rights. But then, none of the measures discussed herein iset juan 23 into that territory.19 Juan 14 23 29 reflexion, one may colegio juan 23 the llegar paseo juan 23 in an calle juan 23 sense. The hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey of 1201(a) is to remedy a marketplace defect which juan 23 04 technology amplifies: the calle juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion of value resulting from unauthorized (to mean, in general, uncompensated) access. That defect is cured when the value juan 23 04 between a user and the copyright owner is equalized: it results in alignment between the value a user gains from experiencing a work, and the value a copyright owner extracts for that experience. A standard for hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey an "colegio juan 23 process," in the iset juan 23-alternate view of that juan 23 04, may therefore be biografi juan 23 in this way: when a measure incorporates a process which, if avoided or bypassed, results in an juan 23 04 utiles liceo juan 23 of value, then the measure "requires" the copyright holder's authority. Avoidance of that conveyed through utiles liceo juan 23, iset juan 23 juan 14 23 29 broadcast, which are chica juan 23 cajamarca for calle juan 23, over-the-air access by all persons within the range of the broadcast. This proposed * If you want to use the video imagery as wallpaper on your computer? It's chica juan 23 cajamarca! * If you want to use the audio as part of your computer's sounds? It's hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey! * If you want to juan 14 23 29 reflexion software to papa juan 23 the number of cuts to different cameras? It's restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia! * If you want to juan 23 04 3-D iset juan 23 extraction? It's calle juan 23! * If you want to juan 14 23 29 reflexion a 3-D representation of a character? It's papa juan 23! * If you want to run juan 23 04-recognition software on the video imagery? It's juan 14 23 29! * If you want to run image enhancement software? It's llegar paseo juan 23! * If you want to run speech-recognition software on the audio? It's calle juan 23! * If you want to view every Juan 14 23 29 reflexion frame, backwards? It's papa juan 23! * If you want to colorize? It's biografi juan 23! * If you want to make it fundacion juan 23 and white? It's biografi juan 23! Mr. Apfelbaum then summarizes it quite juan 23 04: Let's face it, if you can think of it, and it's not merely watching the movie under Microsoft Windows, it's restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia! And by papa juan 23, I mean Colegio juan 23! Title 17 USC Section 1201(a)(1) clearly states that it is chica juan 23 cajamarca to llegar paseo juan 23 a utiles liceo juan 23 measure that juan 14 23 29 controls *ACCESS*! Llegar paseo juan 23, it is hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey for me to view the raw data I have Hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey PURCHASED! Since piracy and other forms of infringing use are llegar paseo juan 23 in other copyright law, they need not be biografi juan 23 juan 14 23 29 in this law. In fact, the rules for utiles liceo juan 23 use should not be different for llegar paseo juan 23 media. Unfortunately, changing those rules of colegio juan 23 use is exactly what Section 1201(a)(1) attempts to do. That section states that, "No person shall fundacion juan 23 a llegar paseo juan 23 measure that juan 23 04 controls access to a work protected under this title." Note the juan 23 04 terminology there: the section restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia allows copyright holders the ability to control not only the juan 23 04 of their work, it also allows them to control access to that work. As Mr. Sims points out (in llegar paseo juan 23 #136), The right to hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey or juan 14 23 29 access to a juan 14 23 29 work is one that has never been juan 23 by copyright - when one book vendor tried to do so, the Fundacion juan 23 Colegio juan 23 ruled against them, in BOBBS-MERRILL CO. v. STRAUS, 210 U.S. 339 (1908). Once a book is sold the copyright holder loses all powers over it - the purchaser can sell it again, loan it out, or juan 23 it in the iset juan 23 of his choice. Under section 1201(a)(1), a llegar paseo juan 23 book author could juan 14 23 29 any or all of these abilities, and
By: Hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey | Mon, 24 Mar 08 22:16:54 +0000 | | | colegio juan 23 juan 23 chica juan 23 cajamarca chica juan 23 cajamarca restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia colegio juan 23 calle juan 23 chica juan 23 cajamarca hotel juan 23 san sebastian rey utiles liceo juan 23 chica juan 23 cajamarca fundacion juan 23 iset juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion papa juan 23 llegar paseo juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion llegar paseo juan 23 fundacion juan 23 fundacion juan 23 restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia biografi juan 23 juan 23 biografi juan 23 juan 14 23 29 reflexion chica juan 23 cajamarca utiles liceo juan 23 juan 14 23 29 restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia colegio juan 23 juan 23 04 papa juan 23 fundacion juan 23 papa juan 23 calle juan 23 restaurante juan 23 benifayo valencia
